Law of Variable Proportions

Introduction

The Law of Variable Proportions describes how the output of a production process changes when the quantity of one input (like labor) is increased while keeping all other inputs (like capital, land, or machinery) constant.

The concept of diminishing returns has its roots in classical economics. David Ricardo and Thomas Malthus explored this phenomenon in relation to agricultural production. Their work laid the foundation for modern production theories.

The law states:
"As more units of a variable input are combined with fixed inputs, the total product initially increases at an increasing rate, then at a decreasing rate, and eventually declines."

In simpler terms:

• Imagine a farmer with a fixed piece of land (capital). As they add more laborers to this land, the output (harvest) will initially increase, but beyond a point, the additional output from each extra laborer starts to decrease. This is the essence of the law.

---

Assumptions of the Law

Before diving into the details, here are the basic assumptions:

1. Constant Technology: Technology used in production remains unchanged.
2. Fixed Factors of Production: Some inputs (like land, machinery) are fixed.
3. Divisibility of Inputs: Variable inputs can be divided into smaller units.
4. Homogeneity of Inputs: All units of variable input are identical in quality and quantity.

---

Three Stages of the Law of Variable Proportions

The law is best understood by analyzing the three distinct stages of production. Let’s explain each stage with a table, graph, and practical examples.

1. Stage I: Increasing Returns

• What Happens?
  At this stage, as more units of the variable input are added, the total product increases at an increasing rate. The marginal product (MP) of each additional input is positive and rising.

• Why?
  This happens because the fixed inputs (e.g., land or machines) are underutilized, and the variable inputs complement them effectively.

• Example:
  Imagine one worker on a farm. Adding a second worker means tasks can now be shared, increasing efficiency.

• Key Point:
  This stage ends when the marginal product is at its maximum.

Input (Labor)	Total Product (TP)	Marginal Product (MP)	Average Product (AP)
1	10	10	10
2	25	15	12.5
3	45	20	15

---

2. Stage II: Diminishing Returns

• What Happens?
  Here, the total product continues to increase but at a decreasing rate. The marginal product starts to decline but remains positive.

• Why?
  The fixed inputs become a constraint. For example, too many workers on a small piece of land can lead to overcrowding.

• Example:
  On a farm with limited land, as more laborers are added, each has less space to work efficiently.

• Key Point:
  This stage is most relevant for decision-making because the firm operates within this stage for profitability.

Input (Labor)	Total Product (TP)	Marginal Product (MP)	Average Product (AP)
4	60	15	15
5	70	10	14
6	75	5	12.5

---

3. Stage III: Negative Returns

• What Happens?
  In this stage, adding more units of the variable input causes the total product to decline. The marginal product becomes negative.

• Why?
  Overcrowding and inefficiencies dominate. The variable input exceeds the capacity of fixed inputs, leading to a fall in output.

• Example:
  Adding a tenth laborer to a small farm might lead to workers getting in each other’s way, reducing overall productivity.

• Key Point:
  No rational producer will operate in this stage.

Input (Labor)	Total Product (TP)	Marginal Product (MP)	Average Product (AP)
7	70	-5	10
8	65	-10	8.12

---

Graph

• Stage I: TP increases at an increasing rate; MP rises.
• Stage II: TP increases at a decreasing rate; MP falls but is positive.
• Stage III: TP declines; MP becomes negative.

Here is the graph illustrating the three stages of the Law of Variable Proportions:

1. X-Axis: Units of the variable input (e.g., labor).
2. Y-Axis: Total Product (TP), Marginal Product (MP), Average Product (AP).

1. Stage I: Increasing Returns (from 1 to 3 units of input)

   • Both Total Product (TP) and Average Product (AP) increase.
   • Marginal Product (MP) is also rising.

2. Stage II: Diminishing Returns (from 4 to 6 units of input)

   • TP continues to increase but at a decreasing rate.
   • MP decreases but remains positive.
   • AP also starts to decline.

3. Stage III: Negative Returns (beyond 6 units of input)

   • TP starts to decrease.
   • MP becomes negative.
   • AP continues to fall, but never touches x axis.

---

Real-Life Applications of the Law

1. Agriculture:
   Overcrowding of labor on a fixed land size leads to diminishing returns.

2. Manufacturing:
   Adding more workers to a machine beyond its capacity results in inefficiency.

3. Service Sector:
   Increasing staff in a small office without adding resources like computers can reduce efficiency.

---

Key Takeaways

1. Memorize the stages and their characteristics.
2. Understand the assumptions and limitations of the law.
3. Be prepared to explain the graph and solve numerical problems on marginal, average, and total products.

The Law of Variable Proportions is a fundamental concept that explains how inputs behave in the short run. By grasping this law, you can better understand production processes and resource allocation.